Broadheads are designed to hunt larger game, such as deer and bears, and typically deliver a low energy impact. This makes shot placement essential and the blades must be razor sharp. There are fixed blade and mechanical blade options available.
Mechanical blade broadheads can offer much better penetration and cutting to hunters, resulting in more effective entry and exit wounds. They fly much closer to a field point, giving a greater shot accuracy. However, they have had a reputation of going wrong due to the moving parts. They have much improved in recent years, leading to an increasing popularity.
Fixed blade broadheads have no moving parts and are the most popular and easiest to use. They come with 2, 3 or 4 blade options. So which one should you use? It depends on the game you are hunting, as to how much penetration you will need.
In the review section, we will go through some of the best fixed blade broadheads, best two blade and three blades broadheads in the market.
Differences between 2 blade, 3 blade and even 4 blade broadheads
Broadheads with 2 blades offer extra deeper penetration, so are well suited for hunting dangerous game. If you are using a bow with a low weight, you would also benefit from a broadhead with a better penetration. Low energy set-ups work best with 2 blade designs. 2 blade fixed broadheads have been around the longest and are therefore tried and tested.
Broadheads with 3 blades are designed to leave better and shorter blood trails, so are well suited to hunting game such as whitetail. The more blades there are, the more resistance and tissue damage there will be.
3 blade broadheads come in many varieties. The main advantage is a superior flight, with the additional benefits of the blades being easy to sharpen and re-sharpen and more cutting blade length.
The ratio between the length and width of blades is also important, as those with a 3:1 ratio cause blade rotation upon impact. This enhances the bone-splitting capabilities and larger wound channels. Some of the 3 blade broadheads give a near perfect 3:1 ratio.
4 blade broadheads are technically 2 blade broadheads, with replaceable bleeder blades. 4 blade broadheads create a much bigger wound channel, meaning the blood trail will be larger and easier to follow. The penetration is not as good as a 2 blade option, but with game such as deer this is not too big an issue.
So when you have chosen which option is best for you, take a look at the following fixed blade broadheads for some very reputable product suggestions.
2 Blade Fixed Broadheads Review
Carbon Express Nativ Broadhead
This 2 blade model has an aircraft-grade aluminium ferrule, which gives it excellent lightweight strength. It is very versatile, meaning the hunter can use it with both low and high poundage bows. With a cutting diameter of 1.125 inches, it delivers a lethal blow for an ethical kill. Designed with field point accuracy, the blades on this broadhead are incredibly sharp. It is a simple broadhead, making it ideal for beginners.
Described as the ‘strongest, sharpest, most accurate broadhead ever’. It flies with absolute field point precision and has incredible penetration. Made from 10% stainless steel, the patented cut-on-contact head delivers a killer blow. It has a 1.25 inches cutting diameter and comes with replaceable blades. They are particularly suited to a recurve bow and leave shorter blood trails than some of their competitors. The brand is well known and respected throughout the industry and many hunters enjoy years of lucrative hunting with them.
Stinger 2 Blade
This is a patented design and is extremely popular among hunters. Made from top quality stainless steel, it is razor sharp and durable. Aircraft quality aluminum is used for the ferrule and it has a patented diamond tip making them one of the best two blade broadheads in the market.
These broadheads are spin tested and offer field point accuracy. They cause maximum devastation when hitting hides and bone and create good entry and exit wounds.
These broadheads even come with a lifetime replacement guarantee, making them not only durable but incredibly good value too. They are made by Magnus Outdoor Products, which is a reputable company within the industry and has a range of top quality products to choose from.
3 Blade Fixed Broadheads Review
G5 Outdoors Montec 3 Blade
Many hunters think these are the stand out, best broadheads for hunting deer, offering the same degree of accuracy as mechanical broadheads. The cut-on-contact design is 25% sharper than the original Montec and they have a cutting diameter of 1-1/16 inches. They are ideal for use with a compound bow but will also work well with a crossbow. Spin testing and Monoflow technologies give great accuracy and the blades are multi-tapered to give extra sharpness. These fixed blade broadheads are easy to sharpen, meaning they can be used multiple times. Due to the size of the cutting diameter, these are one of the best 3 blade broadheads for hunting whitetail.
Muzzy Trocar 3 Blade
Described as Muzzy’s most accurate broadhead, this model has a Helix Blade design which helps to spin and stabilize the broadhead. With a cutting diameter of 1-3/16 inches, it provides a lethal blow. Muzzy is well known for making durable arrowheads and this model is no different. They can be used with both compound and crossbows and are perfect for hunting deer size game. The sharp blades can be re-sharpened, giving the hunter plenty of scope for practice. It is a quiet broadhead, ideal for stealth, and absolutely devastating.
NAP Hellrazor 3 Blade
Made from 100% steel, this is a great cut-on-contact fixed broadhead. Used with a fast performance bow, it delivers field point accuracy and excellent penetration. The cutting diameter is 1-1/8 inches and it is ideal for hunting game of all sizes. There is a designated practice head, enabling hunters to keep their set-up perfectly tuned. The Photon blade bonding process provides the ultimate strength and consistency, ensuring the hunter need not ever worry. New Archery Products is a very reputable brand, with the industry holding it in great esteem.
4 Blade Fixed Broadheads Review
Muzzy Phantom 4 Blade
Another broadhead from one of the most respected companies in the industry, this one is a 4 blade option. It has a cutting diameter of 1-1/16 inches and is made entirely from high-strength stainless steel. This was designed to be used with high-speed hunting crossbows, but can also be used with compound bows, and delivers a devastating blow. These broadheads can be used on a variety of game, from deer to turkey, and provide the hunter with the ability to deliver a good, clean kill. They are easy to install and remove and are a simple, well-made design.
Wasp Boss SST 4 Blade
This popular broadhead is razor-sharp and has a cutting diameter of 1-1/16 inches. The aerodynamic aluminum ferrule offers increased cutting, along with large entry and exit wounds. This leads to huge blood trails, making it easier for the hunter to follow the wounded animal. There is a stainless steel Trocar tip, making it split through bone effortlessly. It provides field point accuracy and it made 100% in the USA. Wasp Archery invented the first broadhead with replaceable blades in 1972 and they have been setting the bar high ever since. This model is no different and the replacement blades offer durability and good value.
Zwickey No Mercy
Zwickey Archery Inc. has been providing top quality broadheads since the 1930s and their No Mercy models are no exception. Available with both 2 blade or 4 blade versions, they offer a choice to suit your needs. The 4 blade version has either single or double bevel edges. A single bevel gives a rotation upon striking the animal, leading to a better wound channel.
These fixed broadheads are suitable for hunting any sized game, although they are ideal for deer, and are very sharp and durable. The bleeders create a much bigger entry and exit holes and the blood trail is greater too.
Downsides of Fixed Blade Broadhead
There are some negative points to consider when using a fixed blade broadhead, such as they are more likely to veer off course when used with a faster bow than a mechanical blade broadhead.
Compound bows are becoming faster and faster in design, so mechanical broadheads are growing in popularity. This does not mean there is no longer a place for fixed blades and at least you won’t have the worry of something going wrong and the blades not opening upon contact. This means that it is all down to you and your shooting skills, so get practicing.
Some energy is lost when mechanical blades open up, meaning the impact is lower energy than that of a fixed blade broadhead. If you are hunting larger game, such as elk, a fixed blade option may be more suitable. This very much depends on what bow you are using and the poundage, etc.
Still Not Sure Between Fixed Blade or Mechanical Broadheads?
Check out the video below to see the difference between fixed and mechanical broadheads.
Whichever style of fixed broadhead you choose, you will not be disappointed. They all offer a simple design and ease of use, which is especially important to beginners. The most important thing to remember is to practice and ensure that all of your equipment is appropriate to be used together. Check it all before you go out and stay safe.